KAFKAESQUE BASEBALL
Payton Tolle

Payton Tolle

Boston Red Sox · 2026 · left-handed starter

68ARSENAL GRADE
100K-STUFF+
Open the full report cardOpen in Pitch Lab

2026 season

G 26GS 26IP 148.2ERA 3.03FIP 3.04WHIP 1.10K% 28.4BB% 6.6K-BB% 21.8ERA+ 138

The short version

His curveball. It comes in with 82.9 mph (90th percentile among lefty curveballs), and hitters miss on 42% of their swings (96th percentile) and chase it 45% of the time out of the zone (100th percentile). The four-seamer backs it up with 96.1 mph (90th percentile among lefty four-seamers), missing bats on 27% of swings.

The cutter to lefties: +1.7 runs per 100 pitches vs. league with a whiff+ of 131.

Pitch grades

PitchGradevs LHHvs RHH
4-Seam605959
Cutter585259
Sinker575059
Curveball56–57
Changeup46–46

20 to 80 scale, 50 is league average.

Arsenal

PitchUsageVeloIVBHB
4-Seam44.6%96.1 mph15.6"9.8" arm side
Sinker24.1%94.8 mph9.8"17.0" arm side
Cutter19.3%88.7 mph7.2"2.4" glove side
Curveball9.3%82.9 mph-4.6"6.9" glove side
Changeup2.8%88.7 mph1.3"10.7" arm side

Pitch Lab

A better pitch mix is worth about +1.1 runs a season.

See the full Pitch Lab breakdown →

Arsenal grade measures how well Tolle uses the pitches he has. K-Stuff+ is our stuff model, where 100 is league average. Read the glossary.