Payton Tolle
Boston Red Sox · 2026 · left-handed starter
68ARSENAL GRADE
100K-STUFF+
2026 season
G 26GS 26IP 148.2ERA 3.03FIP 3.04WHIP 1.10K% 28.4BB% 6.6K-BB% 21.8ERA+ 138
The short version
His curveball. It comes in with 82.9 mph (90th percentile among lefty curveballs), and hitters miss on 42% of their swings (96th percentile) and chase it 45% of the time out of the zone (100th percentile). The four-seamer backs it up with 96.1 mph (90th percentile among lefty four-seamers), missing bats on 27% of swings.
The cutter to lefties: +1.7 runs per 100 pitches vs. league with a whiff+ of 131.
Pitch grades
| Pitch | Grade | vs LHH | vs RHH |
|---|---|---|---|
| 4-Seam | 60 | 59 | 59 |
| Cutter | 58 | 52 | 59 |
| Sinker | 57 | 50 | 59 |
| Curveball | 56 | – | 57 |
| Changeup | 46 | – | 46 |
20 to 80 scale, 50 is league average.
Arsenal
| Pitch | Usage | Velo | IVB | HB |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 4-Seam | 44.6% | 96.1 mph | 15.6" | 9.8" |
| Sinker | 24.1% | 94.8 mph | 9.8" | 17.0" |
| Cutter | 19.3% | 88.7 mph | 7.2" | 2.4" |
| Curveball | 9.3% | 82.9 mph | -4.6" | 6.9" |
| Changeup | 2.8% | 88.7 mph | 1.3" | 10.7" |
Pitch Lab
A better pitch mix is worth about +1.1 runs a season.
- Sinker: Take away 2" of vertical break (more drop) (9.8 → 7.8") (about +0.7 runs a season)
- 4-Seam: Add 2" of glove-side break (9.7 → 7.7") (about +0.3 runs a season)
Arsenal grade measures how well Tolle uses the pitches he has. K-Stuff+ is our stuff model, where 100 is league average. Read the glossary.