Every 2026 arsenal, graded
Search any pitcher to see his arsenal grade and full report card. Arsenal grade measures how efficiently a pitcher uses his pitches. Each card also shows K-Stuff+, our own stuff model, and Whiff+, which grades every pitch against the league average for that pitch type, so a fastball that misses bats gets the credit plain whiff% doesn’t give it.
All 30 staffs, ranked
Every staff ranked by run value, an outcome-based stat, next to its payroll. Each pitcher shows his arsenal grade, K-Stuff+ and best pitch.
Every pitcher, the stats you know
ERA, FIP, K-BB% and WHIP for every 2026 pitcher, plus his arsenal grade. Sort any column, filter by role, export to CSV.
Which pitches fit which arms
Pick a pitcher or enter any arm’s numbers. See which pitch shapes fit his arm slot and what to change.
Writing
My pitching and prospect analysis at Pitcher List, plus Substack favorites.
Young arms with stuff ahead of results
A quick look at young arms whose pitches grade better than their 2026 results.
New to the numbers? Read the glossary · About Ben
Get new pieces by email
Breakout picks, pitch design deep dives and new tools, straight from my Substack. Free.
Or subscribe on Substack →Free Agency Tracker
Every free-agent pitcher this winter, graded · signings update live from MLB
Checking MLB for signings…
| Status |
|---|
Free agents from MLB.com's 2026–27 list; ages are 2027 seasonal ages. Est. AAV is the average annual value we expect him to sign for. Once he signs or a decision keeps him off the market, the column shows his real deal (years, total and AAV) as reported in the headlines, with our estimate underneath. For the five pitchers with published predictions (Bleacher Report, ESPN's insider panel, Spotrac, The Athletic's Jim Bowden), it's the average of those. For everyone else it's our estimate: projected 2027 WAR, built from his run value over the last four seasons (newest weighted most, pulled toward average), a full workload for his role scaled by how much he's actually pitched, and an age adjustment, at about $9M per win for starters and $12.6M for relievers, who get paid more per win. Arsenal grades are from each pitcher's 2026 regular season, or his most recent season with 300+ pitches when marked. ERA, IP, K-BB%, ERA+ and FIP are 2026 regular-season stats from MLB (ERA+ is not park-adjusted; FIP uses the 2026 league constant). Club, mutual and player options can still be exercised, which takes a pitcher off the market. Signings come from MLB's transaction feed, option decisions from MLB's rosters and news headlines, and contract terms from the headlines that report them. Click a name for his full report card.
Today's Matchups
Starting pitchers, what they do best, and how the other lineup handles it
Games, probable pitchers and lineups load live from MLB. Pitcher and team grades use 2026 regular-season Statcast data. Lineups usually post 2–4 hours before first pitch.
Loading games…
Going Deep
Analysis for Pitcher List · 5 articles · select one to read
What Does Milwaukee Do With Andrew Fischer?
A 22-year-old who hit 48 homers across High-A and Double-A, in an organization built on contact. Does his power fit, or does the strikeout rate win out?
Read on Pitcher List →100 mph and a Forkball: Why the Bullpen Makes Sense for Kodai Senga
His results fade the second time through a lineup, and his stuff jumps in short bursts. The case for relief, and what still has to improve.
Read on Pitcher List →Below Average Stuff, Above Average Results: The Guardians Way
Tanner Bibee and Parker Messick win with middling Stuff+ grades. Contact management, sequencing and pitch mix as an organizational pattern.
Read on Pitcher List →The Mets Are Reshaping Jonah Tong
His arm angle dropped from the steep slot he used in the minors, and the whiffs went with it. The new cutter as part of a bigger plan.
Read on Pitcher List →Antonio Senzatela and the Rockies’ New Data-Driven Philosophy
A new cutter, fewer four-seamers and a bullpen role. What Senzatela's turnaround says about how Colorado now builds pitchers.
Read on Pitcher List →Substack
Favorites from my own newsletter · 12 articles · select one to read
Two 2027 Breakouts, and the Changes That Would Unlock Them
My watch list's picks: J.T. Ginn and Yoendrys Gómez, with the pitch mix and shape changes Pitch Lab and Pitch Design suggest for each.
Read on Substack →The Modern Evolution of Pitching Development
How teams are building run prevention from within: pitch-shape design, deeper arsenals and hiring development staff from the best pitching programs.
Read on Substack →Roster Flexibility as Risk Mitigation
Why rosters with value spread across many players have higher floors over 162 games, and why stars still set the ceiling.
Read on Substack →Nothing Fishy About This Marlins Rebuild
Peter Bendix's methodical rebuild: a deadline sell-off for 15 prospects, development changes and cheap depth, with a Rays blueprint.
Read on Substack →Braden Davis: Prospect Evaluation
A High-A lefty with a plus changeup. Command decides whether he's a back-end starter or a high-leverage reliever.
Read on Substack →Khadim Diaw: Prospect Evaluation
A raw contact hitter with real speed who catches and plays the outfield, and whose long-term position is still open.
Read on Substack →Zach Ehrhard: Prospect Evaluation
The outfielder from the Dustin May trade. A 45 future value, with plate discipline and speed carrying uneven power.
Read on Substack →Trey Gibson: Prospect Evaluation
A 6'5" righty at Triple-A Norfolk with a 55 future value. A possible back-end starter as soon as 2026.
Read on Substack →First Place Brew Crew
How a low-payroll Milwaukee roster got to the best record in baseball, and whether that formula holds up in October.
Read on Substack →Cubs Revamped Bullpen
Brad Keller, Daniel Palencia and Drew Pomeranz turned a weakness into a strength. What changed and what might regress.
Read on Substack →Pre-Arbitration Extension Analysis
Roman Anthony's 8-year, $130 million deal: the savings if he keeps it up, and the risk early extensions carry.
Read on Substack →Kodai Senga: New York Mets Unconventional Ace
A 2.31 ERA built on the ghost fork. Why expected stats point to regression, and what his cutter and walks need.
Read on Substack →Pitcher Search
Pitch Mix Tool · every pitcher with 300+ pitches in a season, 2021 to 2026
By count
| Pitch | Aheadmore strikes | Even | Behindmore balls |
|---|
What changed since 2025
| Pitch | Usage 2025 → 2026 | Velo | IVB | HB | Runs/100 | Changes |
|---|
Graded against every 2026 MLB pitch of the same type, thrown with the same hand to the same batter side. Whiff+ and Location+ of 100 are league average. Location+ grades where he put each pitch compared with an average spot for that pitch type, batter side and count. Under Runs/100, the small line splits it into strikes (Str), balls (Ball) and contact (Con); the three add up to the total. Runs/100 is run value per 100 pitches versus league; positive saved runs. Location view: Zone% is the share of pitches in the strike zone, Chase% is the swing rate on pitches outside it, and in-zone whiff% is misses on swings at strikes, each shown against league. Velo is average release speed in mph. IVB is induced vertical break and HB is horizontal break, both in inches; positive HB breaks toward the pitcher’s arm side. xwOBAcon is expected damage on balls in play; negative is better for the pitcher, and it is grayed out under 20 balls in play. Pitches thrown fewer than 10 times to a side or in a count are left off. In the count table, usage is the share of his pitches in that count, and gray marks fewer than 30 swings.
2027 Watch List
Young arms whose stuff is ahead of their results
Breakouts usually show up in the stuff before they show up in the results. This list looks at 2026 pitchers who are 29 or younger, threw 600+ pitches, were average or worse (+0.3 runs per 100 pitches or less) and have never had a strong season since 2021, then ranks starters and relievers separately by projected 2027 run value. It's a watch list, not a promise: most of these pitchers won't break out.
How the projection works
It's a weighted blend, fit on every pitcher with 300+ pitches in back-to-back seasons from 2021 to 2026, that predicts next year's runs per 100 pitches. It leans most on K-Stuff+ (how good the pitches are, ignoring results) and Whiff+ (missed bats against the same pitch type), then Location+, a fastball velocity gain from the year before, and contact quality. This season's run value carries little weight, because one season of results is mostly noise: K-Stuff+ and Whiff+ each predicted the next season better than the results did.
The test: for each season from 2022 to 2025, the model was built using only earlier seasons and picked its top 10 starters and top 10 relievers for the next year. A breakout means the next season was worth 10+ runs above average and at least 8 runs better than the year before. "Never had a strong season" means no season since 2021 worth 10+ runs above average, at +1.0 runs per 100 pitches or better, or with an arsenal grade of 60+. That keeps veterans bouncing back from a bad year off the list.
Age decides who's eligible (29 or younger) rather than counting as a signal. Adding age and years in the majors to the model didn't improve it consistently in testing, so they're shown but not weighted.
What it can't see: injuries and health history, role changes, a new team or a pitch added in the offseason. The reliever list has tested better than the starter list. In 2021, MLB's mid-season crackdown on sticky substances changed some pitchers' spin. Check back next October to see how this list did.
Every past pick and how it went
| List | Pitcher | Age | Runs/100 that year | Next year | Broke out? |
|---|
Pitch Lab
What each pitcher could change · how often to throw each pitch, and how to reshape it
Teams make elite pitchers out of ordinary ones all the time. They pick up an arm nobody is excited about, have him throw his best pitch more and his worst pitch less, tweak a grip or two, and a middle reliever turns into a closer. Pitch Lab looks for those changes in every 2026 MLB pitcher.
Illustrative numbers. Pick a real pitcher above to see his.
Grade every pitch
Each pitch gets a K-Stuff+ grade (how nasty it is, from velo, movement and spin) and a run value (what hitters actually did against it), separately vs lefties and righties.
Find a better mix
The optimizer shifts usage toward his most valuable pitches. It charges a cost for leaning too hard on one, because hitters adjust to what they see most.
Test a fix
One small tweak at a time: 1 mph more, 2 more inches of break, a new pitch. Only versions that pitchers with a similar arm slot already throw.
We gave the optimizer only 2025 numbers and checked its advice against what really happened in 2026. Pitchers who moved toward its suggestions held steady (53% improved). Pitchers who moved away from them got worse (37% improved). In some cases a team made the exact change it suggested, and the pitcher took off.
What it can't know: whether his body can make the change, how pitches play off each other, or what a hitter is sitting on. These are ideas to test with video and a coach, not orders.
Pitch mix
Pitch fixes
How Pitch Lab works
Pitch mix. Each pitch gets a value against lefties and righties: its own 2026 run value, trusted more as the sample grows, blended with its K-Stuff+ grade. The optimizer moves usage toward the most valuable pitches until the extra value runs out, because a pitch gets less effective the more hitters see it (each extra point of usage is charged against that pitch). Guardrails: no pitch moves more than 20 points, a pitch needs 50+ thrown to that side before it's suggested more, and every pitcher keeps a real fastball. Season runs use his 2026 workload to that side.
Did the mix optimizer work in the past? Run on 2025 data only, it suggested real changes in 452 pitcher-vs-side matchups. Pitchers who moved toward its advice in 2026 held steady (+0.03 runs/100, 53% improved); pitchers who moved away got worse (−0.24, 37% improved). Most of that gap is regression to the mean, though: after controlling for how good each mix was in 2025, following the advice was worth only about +0.03 runs/100. The honest read: it points the right way, and one season isn't enough to prove by how much.
The Bryan Baker test. Given only his 2025 numbers, the optimizer said to throw righties fewer sliders (39% → 26%) and more changeups (17% → 32%). The Rays went further in the same direction: 6% sliders and 38% changeups in 2026, and he became an All-Star closer. Against lefties it agreed on more changeups but wanted more sliders, too; the Rays nearly scrapped the slider.
Diminishing returns. The data alone says pitches got better when thrown more (+0.03 runs/100 per usage point). That's backwards: teams throw a pitch more once it's already working, so cause and effect are tangled. The optimizer uses a cautious charge instead: +10 points of usage costs that pitch 0.30 runs/100.
Pitch fixes. One small change at a time (1 mph, 2 inches of break, 150 rpm or 0.3 ft of extension), re-scored with K-Stuff+ and allowed only if pitchers with a similar arm slot already throw that version, plus the typical version of a pitch he doesn't throw. Backtested on 2025→2026 pitch changes: the model predicted which pitches gained or lost whiffs (r = 0.23; 62% right on meaningful changes), but year-to-year run value was too noisy to confirm.
What it can't know. Whether his body can make a change, how pitches play off each other in sequence, or what a hitter is sitting on. Treat these as ideas to test with video and a coach.
Farm Systems
2026 · pitch tracking from Triple-A and the Florida State League, stats from every level
Loading minor league data…
- Strikeout rate
- Walk rate
- Age vs level
System trends
How this system compares with all 30. Pitch-mix trends use Triple-A tracking for every team and Florida State League tracking for the 10 teams with a club there.
| Trend | This system | Average of 30 | Rank |
|---|
Pitchers
Top 10 Pitching Prospects
MLB Pipeline's rankings, not ours. Each organization's 10 highest-ranked pitchers from its Pipeline top 30, in Pipeline's order, with our 2026 numbers alongside. A few systems have fewer than 10 pitchers in their top 30. Click a row for his pitch-by-pitch breakdown.
| Pipeline | Pitcher | Age | Level | Role | IP | K% | BB% | ERA | K-Stuff+ | Grade | Best pitch | FB velo |
|---|
Rankings: MLB Pipeline, as of October 2026. Everything else is ours.
Pitch tracking (velocity, movement, K-Stuff+, grades) exists only where Statcast tracked games in 2026: every Triple-A park and the Single-A Florida State League. Everyone else has regular stats only. K-Stuff+ uses the model trained on 2026 MLB pitches, so a minor leaguer's number is on the big league scale. Pitch grades and runs per 100 compare each pitcher with his own level. Ages are as of July 1, 2026. Called up means he debuted in the majors in 2026 and Debuted 2025 means his first MLB game came last year; both count as prospects here. MLB vet means he debuted before 2025. Click a tag to open his MLB card when he has one. Select any pitcher with pitch tracking to see his usage, shapes and grades.
MLB Pitching Staffs
All 30 pitching staffs, ranked by run value
- Staff rank
- Run value
- Pitching payroll
Rotation
| Pitcher | Pitches | Runs per 100 vs league | Grade | K-Stuff+ | Best pitch |
|---|
Bullpen
| Pitcher | Pitches | Runs per 100 vs league | Grade | K-Stuff+ | Best pitch |
|---|
Run value is runs saved per 100 pitches compared with league average; positive is good. Rotation is anyone who started at least half his games; everyone else is bullpen. Staff identity picks the three stats where this staff ranks most extreme among all 30. Pitchers are grouped by their team as of October 2026. Payroll from Spotrac; Cleveland's wasn't available. Select a pitcher to open his card.
Ballparks
Which batted balls and pitch shapes play up or down in every park
Batted balls
Fly balls by batter side
Pitch shapes
Movement
Leaderboards
2026 season · every MLB pitcher · select a pitcher to open his report card
Stats from MLB for the 2026 regular season. FIP uses the 2026 league constant. Qualified = 1 inning per team game (162). Arsenal grade is ours (20–80, 50 = average) for pitchers with 300+ tracked pitches; see the glossary.
Pitch Design
Which pitch shapes fit which arms · 2026
Every arm slot has pitches that come naturally and pitches that fight it. Pick a pitcher or describe any arm, and see which shapes fit, which of his pitches don’t, and what to change.
Check a pitcher
Any MLB arm from 2026. His arm slot and pitches fill in for you.
Build an arm
Have TrackMan or Rapsodo numbers? Enter an arm angle and his pitches (velo, vertical break, horizontal break). Built for college, JUCO and amateur arms.
The slot cheat sheet
Runs saved per 100 pitches vs league, 2026 · min. 15 pitchers per slotSame pitch, different arm: the running sinker is one of the best shapes from a high slot and the worst from a low one. That’s why the arm comes first.
The shape map · pitcher’s view
Solid outline: fits this arm · Dashed: struggles · Dark dots: his pitches · Select a shapeHis arsenal vs his arm slot
Fit: how the shape played for arm slots like his, runs per 100 pitches vs leagueFit compares each shape’s 2026 run value (runs saved per 100 pitches vs league) among pitchers whose arm angle is within 8° of this one, both hands combined, with at least 12 such pitchers. Targets are the middle half of that shape from those slots. Shapes come from velocity and movement, not the pitch name. This is a starting point for a bullpen session, not a prescription: it can’t see grip comfort, health or sequencing.
Pitch Design
Arm slot changes · what happens when a pitcher raises or drops his arm angle, 2021 to 2026
Statcast measures the angle of a pitcher's arm when he lets go of the ball. When that angle changes by 4 degrees or more from one season to the next, it's one of the biggest changes a pitcher can make, whether a team asked for it or it happened on its own. This page tracks every one since 2021 (335 in all) and what came with it.
Based on 1,955 back-to-back seasons (300+ pitches in both). The shape change is predictable: each degree lower costs a fastball about 0.15" of ride and adds about 0.17" of arm-side run. Whether it works depends on the pitcher. Pitchers who changed slots often were coming off worse seasons, so part of their bounce is the normal swing back toward average. After adjusting for that, the average effect was about +0.05 runs per 100 pitches for a drop and +0.07 for a raise, too small to call.
How it works
Arm angle is each pitcher's average for the season, from Statcast's body tracking. A slot change is a move of 4 degrees or more from one season to the next, for pitchers with 300+ pitches in both. Fastball ride and run compare his main fastball (four-seamer or sinker) across the two seasons, in inches; positive run means more movement toward his arm side. K-Stuff+ and Runs/100 are the change in his pitch-weighted averages. Click a name to open his report card for the newer season.
Result labels are descriptive, not a verdict on the change: Results up means his run value improved by 0.5 per 100 pitches or more, Results down means it fell by that much, and anything in between is About the same.
Limits: arm angle is estimated from body tracking, so very large jumps can be partly measurement. Statcast's arm angles read about 3 degrees lower across the whole league in 2022, which looks like a tracking change, so 2021 to 2022 changes are measured against that league-wide shift. A slot change rarely happens alone: injuries, new pitches and new teams come with it, and this page can't separate those.
Glossary
Every term used on the site
Results
- Usage
- How often a pitcher throws a pitch, as a share of all his pitches to that batter side.
- Whiff%
- Swings and misses divided by total swings.
- Whiff+
- Whiff% compared with league average for the same pitch type, throwing hand and batter side. 100 is average; 120 means 20% more misses.
- Pitch grade
- One 20–80 grade per pitch, the scale scouts use: 50 is average, 60 is plus, 70 is plus-plus, 40 is below average. It blends Whiff+, chase rate, in-zone whiffs, contact quality (xwOBAcon), ground-ball rate and Location+, each weighted by how much it drives run value across 2026. It grades what the pitcher controls, so it's steadier than run value, which includes luck. Small samples are pulled toward 50: a pitch thrown 150 times keeps half its distance from average, one thrown 600 times keeps 80%.
- Arsenal grade
- A pitcher's whole mix on the 20–80 scale, weighting each pitch by how often he throws it. Grades on fewer pitches are pulled toward 50 (halfway at 400 pitches), so a reliever needs a bigger edge than a starter to reach the top. Leaderboards rank starters and relievers separately. A starter is anyone who threw 50+ pitches in at least half his games (or in 10+ games). It rates pitch quality, not workload or durability.
- Matchups
- Each day's probable starters and lineups come live from MLB. For each starter, his run value by pitch group (fastballs, breaking balls, offspeed) is set against how the other team hit that group from pitchers of the same hand in 2026, ranked 1–30 (1 = best offense). Matchup edge = for each group, how often he throws it × (his run value − their run value), added up, in runs per 100 pitches. Hitter chips show each batter's run value vs. league by pitch group, colored from the pitcher's side; under 150 pitches seen is faded because it's mostly noise. It describes the matchup, not a prediction.
- Pitch mix optimizer
- Part of Pitch Lab. Suggests how often to throw each pitch against lefties and righties. Each pitch's value blends its own 2026 run value (trusted more as the sample grows; halfway at 300 pitches) with its K-Stuff+ grade. Usage shifts toward the most valuable pitches, but every extra point of usage is charged against that pitch, because hitters adjust to what they see more. Guardrails: no pitch moves more than 20 points, a pitch needs 50+ thrown to that side before it's suggested more, and every pitcher keeps a real fastball. It treats each pitch on its own, so it can't see how a pitch sets up the next one.
- 2027 Watch List
- Ten starters and ten relievers who are 29 or younger, threw 600+ pitches in 2026, were average or worse and have never had a strong season since 2021, ranked by projected 2027 run value. The projection leans on K-Stuff+ and Whiff+, then Location+, fastball velo change and contact quality. Tested on 2022 to 2025 with lists built only from earlier seasons: 28 of 40 reliever picks and 22 of 40 starter picks were above average the next year (vs 50% and 38% of similar pitchers). It can't see injuries or role changes.
- Arm slot change
- A move of 4 degrees or more in a pitcher's average arm angle from one season to the next (300+ pitches in both). Across 1,955 back-to-back seasons from 2021 to 2026, each degree lower cost a fastball about 0.15" of ride and added about 0.17" of arm-side run, with almost no change in velocity. On its own, a slot change didn't reliably help or hurt results.
- Pitch Lab
- Up to four things each pitcher could try, ranked by runs saved. Usage: an Underused weapon he could throw more. Shape tweak: one small change (1 mph, 2 inches of break, 150 rpm or 0.3 ft of extension) re-scored with K-Stuff+, allowed only if pitchers with a similar arm slot already throw that version. New pitch: the typical version of a pitch he doesn't throw (no second changeup or splitter if he already has an offspeed pitch), built from at least 5 pitchers with his arm slot and fastball velo, shown only if it projects to K-Stuff+ 105 or better. Each comes with a similar-shaped pitch from a real pitcher. The model can't tell whether a pitcher can physically make the change. Backtest: on 367 pitches that changed shape from 2025 to 2026, graded by models that never saw that pitcher, predicted whiff change matched actual whiff change (r = 0.23, still significant after controlling for regression to the mean). The direction was right 62% of the time when the model expected a 2+ point swing, and 68% at 5+ points. Run value changes were mostly noise (52%), so treat the runs-saved estimates as rough.
- K-Stuff+
- K-Stuff+ is my own Stuff+ model, built for this site. It grades the pitch itself, not what happened to it. A model trained on every 2026 pitch learns how velo, movement, spin, release point, extension, arm angle and the gap from his main fastball turn into run value, with separate models for fastballs, breaking balls and offspeed. It never sees location or results. 100 is average; 10 points is 1 standard deviation.
How it's different from FanGraphs Stuff+ and other public models: (1) every pitch gets its own grade against lefties and against righties, and the model knows whether the hitter is on the same side as the pitcher; (2) it uses Statcast's arm angle; (3) it learns from one season at a time, so each year is graded against that year's league; (4) the scale is tighter, so the best single pitches top out in the 120s and 130s and whole arsenals sit closer to 100. The numbers won't match FanGraphs, and they aren't meant to.
Tested honestly: first-half K-Stuff+ predicted second-half run value better than first-half run value did (r = 0.24 vs 0.17). - Location+
- Grades where a pitcher puts each pitch, not what happened after. Every spot around the plate gets the league's average run value for that pitch group, batter side and count, and each pitch is credited for how good its spot usually is. 100 is average; 10 points is one standard deviation. Pitchers with elite stuff often attack the zone on purpose, which can pull theirs down.
- Run value
- How much each pitch changed the expected runs in the inning, from Statcast. Shown per 100 pitches against league average. Positive means it saved runs.
- Run value breakdown
- Splits Runs/100 into where the runs came from: strikes (called, swinging and fouls), balls, and contact (balls in play). The three parts add up to Runs/100. It explains pitches that miss bats but still cost runs: usually they get hit hard when hitters connect, or hitters take them for balls.
- Biggest leak
- On a pitch that costs runs, the part of the breakdown costing the most: not enough strikes, too many balls, or hurt on contact.
- xwOBAcon
- Expected damage on balls in play, built from exit velocity and launch angle. Lower is better for the pitcher. Shown against league average.
- Hard-hit%
- Share of balls in play hit 95 mph or harder.
Location
- Zone%
- Share of pitches in the strike zone.
- Chase%
- How often hitters swing at a pitch outside the zone. The clearest sign a pitch fools people.
- In-zone whiff%
- Misses on swings at strikes. A pitch that gets these beats hitters even when they know it's coming.
Movement and shape
- Velo
- Average release speed, in mph.
- IVB
- Induced vertical break: how much a pitch rises or drops compared with a pitch thrown with no spin, in inches.
- HB
- Horizontal break, in inches. Arm side means toward the pitcher's throwing arm (sinkers, changeups); glove side means away from it (sliders, sweepers).
- Off fastball
- How much slower a pitch is than the pitcher's main fastball, in mph.
- Pitch shape
- A group of pitches that move alike, such as a sweeper or a vertical slider, defined by velocity and break. See Pitch Design.
Arm and delivery
- Arm angle
- The angle of the arm at release, in degrees, from Statcast body tracking. 0° is straight sideways and 90° is straight up.
- Arm slots
- Submarine below 0°, sidearm 0–15°, low three-quarters 15–30°, three-quarters 30–45°, high three-quarters 45–60°, over the top 60°+. A rough guide.
- Pronator / supinator
- How a pitcher's hand naturally moves at release. Pronators turn it over, which helps changeups and sinkers. Supinators get to the side of the ball, which helps sweepers and curves.
Flags
- Underused weapon
- Whiff+ 120 or higher, run value +1.0 or better, and thrown less than 25% of the time.
- Misses bats, still gets hurt
- Whiff+ 120 or higher, but run value −1.0 or worse.
- Below league average
- Run value −1.5 or worse.
- Heavy use, below average
- Thrown 25% of the time or more, with run value below zero.
- Hit hard on contact
- 20+ balls in play and xwOBAcon .040 or more above league.
- Good stuff, bad spots
- Whiff+ 110 or higher, Location+ 90 or lower, and run value below zero. The pitch is fine; where it's thrown is the problem.
- Gets by on location
- Whiff+ 90 or lower, Location+ 110 or higher, and run value above zero. He wins with command, not nastiness.
- Small sample
- Fewer than 30 swings, so the pitch isn't graded yet.
Counts and changes
- Ahead / Even / Behind
- Ahead means more strikes than balls (0-1, 0-2, 1-2); behind means more balls than strikes.
- What changed since 2025
- New or dropped pitch, usage up or down 10+ points, velo up or down 1.5+ mph, or 2.5+ inches of new break. An arm slot change is 4°+.
Teams
- Staff run value
- Every pitcher's run value on a staff, weighted by pitches thrown.
- Pitching payroll
- Combined salary of the pitchers on the current roster, from Spotrac.
About
Pitching analysis and tools
Ben Kafka
I work in ticket sales for the Brooklyn Cyclones at Maimonides Park and write pitching analysis for Pitcher List's Going Deep section. I also consult independently for a junior college program, working with its TrackMan data.
Kafkaesque Baseball started as one question: is a pitcher using his pitches the right way? It grew into a tool that answers that for every pitcher in MLB. I designed the analysis and built it in Python with pybaseball, learning the language as I went and working with Claude as a coding partner. Every method, threshold and limit is written out in the notebook.
- Every 2026 pitch. 716,792 regular-season pitches from Statcast, plus 2025 for year-over-year changes.
- Graded against exact peers. Each pitch is compared only to the same pitch type, thrown with the same hand to the same batter side, on whiffs, run value, contact quality and location.
- Flags where usage and results don't match. Underused weapons, pitches that miss bats but still get hurt, pitches that get hit hard.
- Written in plain English. Every card says what makes the pitcher nasty and what his biggest strength is.
- 2026 – nowFreelance Writer
Pitcher List - 2025 – nowAccount Executive, Ticket Sales
Brooklyn Cyclones - 2024 – 2025Account Executive, Ticket Sales
Norfolk Tides - 2024Front Office Coordinator
Norfolk Tides - 2023BS, Sports Management
Old Dominion University
Get new pieces by email
Breakout picks, pitch design deep dives and new tools, straight from my Substack. Free.
Or subscribe on Substack →