KAFKAESQUE BASEBALL
Dustin May

Dustin May

Milwaukee Brewers · 2026 · right-handed starter

46ARSENAL GRADE
103K-STUFF+
Open the full report cardOpen in Pitch Lab

2026 season

G 31GS 31IP 145.2ERA 4.70FIP 3.63WHIP 1.32K% 23.2BB% 8.1K-BB% 15.1ERA+ 89

The short version

His cutter. It comes in with 93.3 mph (91st percentile among righty cutters), and hitters miss on 22% of their swings (67th percentile) and chase it 38% of the time out of the zone (92nd percentile). The sinker backs it up with 17.5" of arm-side run (93rd percentile), missing bats on 15% of swings.

The cutter to lefties: +1.8 runs per 100 pitches vs. league, winning on weak contact rather than whiffs (whiff+ 96).

Pitch grades

PitchGradevs LHHvs RHH
Cutter575851
4-Seam504854
Sinker504752
Curveball4748–
Sweeper384535
Changeup3838–

20 to 80 scale, 50 is league average.

Arsenal

PitchUsageVeloIVBHB
4-Seam24.8%96.9 mph15.2"9.8" arm side
Cutter23.7%93.3 mph9.3"1.3" glove side
Sinker20.1%96.6 mph6.3"17.5" arm side
Sweeper17.7%86.0 mph-3.9"16.1" glove side
Curveball7.6%83.7 mph-15.7"9.1" glove side
Changeup6.0%90.2 mph4.3"15.8" arm side

Pitch Lab

A better pitch mix is worth about +2.3 runs a season.

See the full Pitch Lab breakdown →

Arsenal grade measures how well May uses the pitches he has. K-Stuff+ is our stuff model, where 100 is league average. Read the glossary.